All photos (1)Sara's Restaurant

Sara's Restaurant

9.17 reviews
American
Ranked #1 in Erie restaurants
Popular with:
  • 9.8
    Foodies
  • 9.8
    Family Travelers
Write Review
Bookmark
25 Peninsula Dr, Erie, PA 16505
(814) 833-1957
http://sarasandsallys.com/
Edit info
Sara's, with its retro '50s decor, might look old, but it actually opened (as an ice cream stand) in 1980. They still serve ice cream (the orange sherbet/vanilla twist is a local ... Read more
favorite), but have become famous for their grilled burgers and Smith's hot dogs. Every April Erieites line up on opening day to get their first taste of summer. There's an actual vintage diner (1957) out back called Sally's, which is used for overflow seating and a gift shop.

Member Reviews(7)

Reviews
9.1/10
Wonderful!
5
4
3
2
1
Sort by
Most Helpful
Show Local reviews
Local from Pennsylvania, USA

Sara's, with its retro '50s decor, might look old, but it actually opened (as an ice cream stand) in 1980. They still serve ice cream (the orange sherbet/vanilla twist is a local favorite), but have become famous for their grilled burgers and Smith's hot dogs. Every April Erieites line up on opening day to get their first taste of summer. There's an actual vintage diner (1957) out back called Sally's, which is used for overflow seating and a gift shop.

Recommended for:Budget TravelersFamily TravelersFoodies
Helpful
Report

A spot not to miss! Sara's is the legendary burger and dog joint - best onion rings ever!

Recommended for:Family TravelersFoodies
Helpful
Report
Burns, Kansas

Your visit to Presque Isla wouldn't be complete without stopping by this local legend for a quick snack!

Helpful
Report
Elyria, Ohio

THE place to eat on Presque Isle. Hot dogs, hamburgers, fries and onion rings. Ice cream too! Try their malts!

Recommended for:Family Travelers
Helpful
Report
Akron, Ohio
First to Review

One of my favorite places to go for a quick all american meal and home of my favorite, the "turtle sundae". Located on Peninsula Drive just before the entrance to the beaches!

Helpful
Report
Burns, Kansas

best ice cream!

Recommended for:Family TravelersFoodies
Helpful
Report
Helpful
Report
Sara's Restaurant

Show Nearby Places

Loading...
42.11267-80.15491
Clarion Hotel Bel-Aire Conf. Ctr.
Clarion Hotel Bel-Aire Conf. Ctr.
10.01 review
Distance: 0.72 mi
Riviera Motel
Riviera Motel
8.01 review
Distance: 0.66 mi
Sheraton Erie Bayfront Hotel
Sheraton Erie Bayfront Hotel
9.02 reviews
Distance: 3.67 mi
Peek'n Peak Resort and Spa
Peek'n Peak Resort and Spa
10.03 reviews
Distance: 21.81 mi
View all
Waldameer & Water World
Waldameer & Water World
9.89 reviews
Entertainment, Water Park
Distance: 0.22 mi
Waldameer Park and Water World
Waldameer Park and Water World
9.65 reviews
Other, Entertainment, Water Park
Distance: 0.62 mi
Waldameer Park Rd
Waldameer Park Rd
10.01 review
Distance: 0.59 mi
Presque Isle State Park
Presque Isle State Park
9.730 reviews
Outdoors, Hiking and Nature, Park
Distance: 3.78 mi
View all
Syd's place
Syd's place
10.01 review
American
Distance: 0.62 mi
Romolo Chocolates
Romolo Chocolates
9.33 reviews
$$$$
Breakfast & Brunch, Cafe
Distance: 1.93 mi
The Juice Jar
The Juice Jar
10.02 reviews
Cafe, Juice & Smoothies
Distance: 0.78 mi
Joe Roots Grill
Joe Roots Grill
10.02 reviews
$$$$
American, Seafood
Distance: 0.67 mi
View all
Report this place