All photos (1)Casey's New Buffalo

Casey's New Buffalo

8.522 reviews
American, Bar
Popular with:
  • 9.8
    Foodies
  • 7.5
    Art & Design Lovers
  • 7.0
    Nightlife Lovers
  • 6.3
    History Buffs
Write Review
Bookmark
136 N Whittaker St, New Buffalo, MI 49117
(269) 469-6400
http://www.caseysnewbuffalo.com
Edit info
Great to sit outside on the patio, inside has a ton of character. Live music inside on weekends. Great service and the character make it a favorite.

Member Reviews(22)

Reviews
8.5/10
Wonderful!
5
4
3
2
1
Sort by
Most Helpful
Show Local reviews
Chicago, Illinois, USA

Beautiful but very small outdoor dining in the back of the restaurant. You probably will have to wait a while for seating. Food was very good.

Recommended for:FoodiesArt & Design Lovers
Helpful
Report
Glen Ellyn

Bartender was great and personable. He knew a ton on the menu and had excellent recommendations.

The food here was superb. My favorite was the beer cheese soup fondue.

Recommended for:FoodiesHistory BuffsNightlife Lovers
Helpful
Report
Indianapolis, Indiana

Great food and service! Great little outside bar and restaurant seating in the back.

Helpful
Report

GREAT food, cozy atomosphere, workers very knowledgeable of food and local wine and beers. Would absolutely come back here

Recommended for:FoodiesArt & Design Lovers
Helpful
Report

A decent burger, a friendly crowd, and an outdoor patio with live music on the weekends.

Helpful
Report

Great to sit outside on the patio, inside has a ton of character. Live music inside on weekends. Great service and the character make it a favorite.

Helpful
Report
Harbert, Michigan, USA
First to Review

There are bars at several of the local restaurants (Red Arrow Roadhouse, Stray Dog) but if you're looking for a real bar that's open late, this is the only deal in town. They have a decent wine list, OK food, and it's open later than anything else.

Helpful
Report
Burns, Kansas

Great outdoor patio and bar. Lake perch dinner is good.

Recommended for:Foodies
Helpful
Report
Palatine, Illinois

Food is just so-so, but the drinks and atmosphere is great!

Helpful
Report
La Porte, Indiana

Diverse menu...come early gets crowded.

Helpful
Report
Bridgman, Michigan

Good food, nice bar and a great spot for outside eating in the Summer.

Helpful
Report
South Bend, Indiana

great crab cakes and mushroom stuffed ravioli

Helpful
Report
Burns, Kansas

Casey’s offers casual fine dining that includes hand-cut steaks and chops, Italian dishes, fresh seafood and daily specials, as well as lighter fare like dinner salads and sandwiches. We serve a variety of draft beers, including micro-brews, and cocktails and offer an extensive wine list.

Helpful1
Report
Elmwood Park, Illinois
Helpful
Report
Helpful
Report
Mishawaka, Indiana
Helpful
Report
Oak Lawn, Illinois
Recommended for:Foodies
Helpful
Report
Recommended for:Nightlife Lovers
Helpful
Report
Recommended for:Budget TravelersNightlife Lovers
Helpful
Report
South Bend, Indiana
Helpful
Report
Casey's New Buffalo

Show Nearby Places

Loading...
41.795837-86.74535
The Harbor Grand
The Harbor Grand
8.02 reviews
Distance: 0.12 mi
Marina Grand Resort
Marina Grand Resort
8.01 review
Distance: 0.43 mi
Four Winds Casino Resort
Four Winds Casino Resort
9.515 reviews
Distance: 2.06 mi
Blue Chip Casino and Hotel
Blue Chip Casino and Hotel
8.37 reviews
Distance: 9.18 mi
View all
RIVER and BEACH KAYAK & PADDLEBOARD RENTALS
RIVER and BEACH KAYAK & PADDLEBOARD RENTALS
8.67 reviews
Tours, Classes and Rentals, Outdoors, Beaches and Watersports, Board Shop
Distance: 0.15 mi
gallion river kayak rentals
gallion river kayak rentals
8.73 reviews
Distance: 0.15 mi
New Buffalo Medical Center
New Buffalo Medical Center
9.02 reviews
Sights and Museums, Landmark
Distance: 0.15 mi
Women's Wellness Center
Women's Wellness Center
10.01 review
Wellness, Beauty and Spas, Spa or Massage
Distance: 0.15 mi
View all
The Stray Dog Bar & Grill
The Stray Dog Bar & Grill
9.160 reviews
$$$$
American, Burgers, Bar
Distance: 0.11 mi
Brewster's Italian Cafe
Brewster's Italian Cafe
9.327 reviews
$$$$
Italian, Pizza
Distance: 0.08 mi
Terrace Room at The Harbor Grand Hotel
Terrace Room at The Harbor Grand Hotel
9.811 reviews
$$$$
Italian
Distance: 0.12 mi
Barneys Market
Barneys Market
9.010 reviews
Specialty Food Stores, Bakery
Distance: 0.15 mi
View all
Report this place