Compare and save on Sanibel Island hotels

Find hotel dealsPlease select a place
Check in:
Check out:
Carl Black -flickr
Sort by Tribes
Best Value
Currency
75 Results
  • Casa Ybel Resort
    Ranked #1 overall in Sanibel Island hotels
    9.33 reviews
    • Free WiFi
    • Swimming Pool
    • Fitness Center
    • Free Parking
    ReviewsPhotosAmenitiesMaploadingclose
  • Sanibel Island Beach Resort
    Ranked #2 overall in Sanibel Island hotels
    6.04 reviews
    Popular withFamilies

    This is the only chain motel on the Island. I remember this same Holiday Inn 40 years ago from my first visit to Sanibel. Prices are typically $300+ per night. ...

    • Restaurant
    • Free Parking
    • Pets Allowed
    ReviewsPhotosAmenitiesMaploadingclose
  • Sanibel Arms West Condominium
    Ranked #3 overall in Sanibel Island hotels
    10.01 review
    Popular withOutdoorsyFamilies

    My family has been going here for decades(forty+ years according to my grandfather) and it's always wonderful. The condos are really cute and it's right on the beach.

    • Free WiFi
    • Swimming Pool
    • Fitness Center
    • Free Parking
    ReviewsPhotosAmenitiesMaploadingclose
  • Tarpon Beach Condos
    Ranked #4 overall in Sanibel Island hotels
    10.02 reviews
    Popular withLuxuryFoodiesFamilies

    Tarpon Beach Condo's consists of 3 buildings with either 9 or 12 units per building for a total of 30 units. This is a low impact condo development especially when ...

    • Free Parking
    ReviewsPhotosAmenitiesMaploadingclose
  • Mitchell's Sandcastles
    Ranked #5 overall in Sanibel Island hotels
    7.02 reviews
    Popular withFamilies

    This place is a gem nestled within some really nice private homes. I reserved The Dunes cottage and it has a nice view of the ocean as well as the ...

    • Free Parking
    • Pets Allowed
    ReviewsPhotosAmenitiesMaploadingclose
  • Island Inn
    Ranked #6 overall in Sanibel Island hotels
    10.01 review
    Popular withOutdoorsyFamilies

    This inn has a true old Florida, quaint cottage vibe. Rooms have been updated with hardwood floors and bathrooms with modern amenities. The grounds are well manicured and the staff ...

    • Free WiFi
    • Restaurant
    • Swimming Pool
    • Free Breakfast
    • Free Parking
    ReviewsPhotosAmenitiesMaploadingclose
  • Sundial Beach Resort & Spa
    Ranked #7 overall in Sanibel Island hotels
    10.01 review
    Popular withFamiliesAdventureWellness

    Wonderful place, family oriented, a little pricey but worth it.

    • Free WiFi
    • Fitness Center
    • Free Parking
    ReviewsPhotosAmenitiesMaploadingclose
  • Shell Island Beach Club
    Ranked #8 overall in Sanibel Island hotels
    10.01 review
    Popular withOutdoorsyFamilies
      ReviewsPhotosAmenitiesMaploadingclose
    • Lighthouse Resort & Club
      Ranked #10 overall in Sanibel Island hotels
      10.01 review
      • Free Parking
      ReviewsPhotosAmenitiesMaploadingclose
    • Our Captiva, LLC
      Ranked #9 overall in Sanibel Island hotels
      10.01 review

      Headquarters of Our Captiva, LLC

        ReviewsPhotosAmenitiesMaploadingclose
      • Sanibel Beach Club
        Ranked #11 overall in Sanibel Island hotels
        8.01 review

        really great beach to take strolls and look for shells :)

        • Free Parking
        ReviewsPhotosAmenitiesMaploadingclose
      • Beachview Cottages
        Ranked #12 overall in Sanibel Island hotels
        8.01 review

        Not fancy but if you want a little bungalow type place that's like Florida was years ago located right on one of the best shelling and walking beaches anywhere, you ...

        • Free WiFi
        • Swimming Pool
        • Free Parking
        • Pets Allowed
        ReviewsPhotosAmenitiesMaploadingclose
      • Blue Dolphin Cottages
        Ranked #15 overall in Sanibel Island hotels
        10.01 review
        Popular withFamiliesOutdoorsyAdventure

        The advantage of the Blue Dolphin is that it's far enough down West Gulf Drive that the beaches are really secluded. My wife's grandparents lived right around the corner and ...

        • Free Parking
        ReviewsPhotosAmenitiesMaploadingclose
      • Colony Inn
        Ranked #16 overall in Sanibel Island hotels
        10.01 review

        Love the Colony Resort!! We always stay in condo #49 it is decorated beautifully, cozy, new king bed - so comfy, new kitchen and bathroom, corner unit so extra window ...

        • Free Parking
        ReviewsPhotosAmenitiesMaploadingclose
      • Royal Shell Vacations Inc
        Ranked #13 overall in Sanibel Island hotels
        10.01 review
          ReviewsPhotosAmenitiesMaploadingclose
        • Cottages to Castles: Sanibel
          Ranked #14 overall in Sanibel Island hotels
          10.01 review

          Key pick up at this place

            ReviewsPhotosAmenitiesMaploadingclose
          • Castaways Beach and Bay Cottages
            Ranked #17 overall in Sanibel Island hotels
            6.01 review
            Popular withAdventure
            • Free WiFi
            • Swimming Pool
            • Free Parking
            • Pets Allowed
            ReviewsPhotosAmenitiesMaploadingclose
          • Pointe Santo de Sanibel
            Ranked #18 overall in Sanibel Island hotels
            5.02 reviews

            The condo development directly to the east is Pointe Santo. This is a much more densely developed condo group with over 100 units compared to Tarpon Beach with only 30. ...

            • Free Parking
            ReviewsPhotosAmenitiesMaploadingclose
          • Shalimar Cottages and Motel
            Ranked #19 overall in Sanibel Island hotels
            2.01 review

            The management claims it's our fault for not checking water conditions before we booked out stay. The once clear gulf now looks like a swamp! Most people are unaware of ...

            • Free WiFi
            • Swimming Pool
            • Free Parking
            ReviewsPhotosAmenitiesMaploadingclose
          • Anchor Inn & Cottages
            Ranked #23 overall in Sanibel Island hotels
            • Free WiFi
            • Swimming Pool
            • Free Parking
            • Pets Allowed
            PhotosAmenitiesMaploadingclose
          • Sanibel Inn
            Ranked #20 overall in Sanibel Island hotels
            0.0
            • Free WiFi
            • Restaurant
            • Swimming Pool
            • Free Parking
            PhotosAmenitiesMaploadingclose
          • Sea Shells of Sanibel
            Ranked #22 overall in Sanibel Island hotels
            0.0
            • Free Parking
            PhotosAmenitiesMaploadingclose
          • Sunset Beach Inn
            Ranked #21 overall in Sanibel Island hotels
            0.0
            • Free WiFi
            • Swimming Pool
            • Free Breakfast
            • Free Parking
            PhotosAmenitiesMaploadingclose
          • Marina Island Resort Pangkor
            Ranked #24 overall in Sanibel Island hotels
              PhotosAmenitiesMaploadingclose
            • West Wind Inn
              Ranked #25 overall in Sanibel Island hotels
              0.0
              • Free WiFi
              • Swimming Pool
              • Fitness Center
              • Free Parking
              PhotosAmenitiesMaploadingclose
            • Gulf Breeze Cottages
              Ranked #26 overall in Sanibel Island hotels
              0.0
              • Free WiFi
              • Free Parking
              PhotosAmenitiesMaploadingclose
            • Waterside Inn on the Beach
              Ranked #27 overall in Sanibel Island hotels
              0.0
              • Free WiFi
              • Swimming Pool
              • Free Parking
              • Pets Allowed
              PhotosAmenitiesMaploadingclose
            • Kings Crown Condominiums
              Ranked #31 overall in Sanibel Island hotels
              0.0
                PhotosAmenitiesMaploadingclose
              • Pelicans Roost
                Ranked #29 overall in Sanibel Island hotels
                0.0
                Popular withLuxury
                • Free WiFi
                • Swimming Pool
                • Free Parking
                PhotosAmenitiesMaploadingclose
              • Song of the Sea
                Ranked #32 overall in Sanibel Island hotels
                0.0
                • Free WiFi
                • Swimming Pool
                • Free Breakfast
                • Free Parking
                PhotosAmenitiesMaploadingclose

              Average price per night

              Hotel class

              Hotel type

              Average user rating

              Clear Filters
              Clear Filters
              var ListPage = { maxTries: 20, interval: 0, xhrRequests: [], update: function(url, count, callback){ var fingerprint = "&t=" + (new Date().getTime()); var reqcount = "&req_count=" + count; this.loader("on"); var self = this; var req = new XMLHttpRequest(); req.open("GET", url + fingerprint + reqcount, true); ListPage.xhrRequests.push(req); req.onreadystatechange = function() { if (req.readyState === 4 && (req.status === 200 || req.status === 202)) { eval(req.responseText); self.loader("off"); if (req.status === 200 || req.status !== 202 ) callback(req.status); if (req.status === 202) { if (count < self.maxTries) { setTimeout(function(){ListPage.update(url, ++count, callback)}, self.interval); self.interval += 100; } else { callback(req.status); } } } }; req.send(null); }, loader: function(status) { var spinnerD = document.querySelector('.spinnersD'); var spinnerM = document.querySelector('.spinnersM'); if (spinnerD && spinnerM) { if (status === "on") { spinnerD.className = "spinnersD shownow"; spinnerM.className = "spinnersM shownow"; } else { // hide spinnerD.className = "spinnersD"; spinnerM.className = "spinnersM"; } } }, ajax: function(url, callback) { this.update(url, 1, callback); } }; ListPage.ajax("https://www.skyscanner.com/trip/hotels/hotel_list_page?action=index&clean_path=sanibel-island-fl&controller=topics&country_code=&current_user_id=&filters=&id=2000000059355&klass_name=Region&list_type=hotels&nearby=false&order=asc&path=sanibel-island-fl%2Fhotels&place=2000000059355&place_type=City&place_type=region&region=2000000059355&sort=best_value", function(status){ if (status === 200) { HotelRates.ajax(); } }); var HotelRates = { hotels: "hotel_ids%5B%5D=5000000171461&hotel_ids%5B%5D=5000000344891&hotel_ids%5B%5D=5000000380844&hotel_ids%5B%5D=5000001372192&hotel_ids%5B%5D=5000000066051&hotel_ids%5B%5D=5000000001687&hotel_ids%5B%5D=5000001319980&hotel_ids%5B%5D=5000003782094&hotel_ids%5B%5D=5000000053376&hotel_ids%5B%5D=5000001481158&hotel_ids%5B%5D=5000000096689&hotel_ids%5B%5D=5000000100918&hotel_ids%5B%5D=5000001367779&hotel_ids%5B%5D=5000000165754&hotel_ids%5B%5D=5000001982577&hotel_ids%5B%5D=5000001611481&hotel_ids%5B%5D=5000000087929&hotel_ids%5B%5D=5000000420020&hotel_ids%5B%5D=5000000327710&hotel_ids%5B%5D=5000000170385&hotel_ids%5B%5D=5000000384177&hotel_ids%5B%5D=5000000194335&hotel_ids%5B%5D=5000000257255&hotel_ids%5B%5D=5000000704488&hotel_ids%5B%5D=5000000234036&hotel_ids%5B%5D=5000000096291&hotel_ids%5B%5D=5000000002334&hotel_ids%5B%5D=5000000243655&hotel_ids%5B%5D=5000000341643&hotel_ids%5B%5D=5000000232830", ajaxCalls: function(tryIndex) { if (this.hotels) { ListPage.update("https://www.skyscanner.com/trip/hotels/hotel_rates_list?bookable_only=&country_code=&current_user_id=&locale=en&region=2000000059355" + "&" + this.hotels, tryIndex, function(){ var placeholder = document.querySelectorAll('.metasearch_featured .placeholder'); for (var i = 0; i < placeholder.length; i++) { placeholder[i].style.display='none'; } }); } }, ajax: function() { this.ajaxCalls(1); }, singleAjax: function() { this.ajaxCalls(ListPage.maxTries); } };